Posted by Mike on March 24, 2009

“He talks too much, campaigns for cretins and clouds the streets of Medfield with his musk. But on many a fine summer night he rose up on his hind legs and walked with the kings. Cheers, sir.”- Mi Lo
A Friend of mine recently posted this on my Facebook page about Curt Schilling. I called him the Hall Monitor because of his goody two shoes persona and penchant for revealing subjects to the press that would make his teammates and management cringe. Some called him “The Blogger”. Others just referred to him as arrogant or a blowhard. Regardless of what we thought of him as a person(as if we really knew him), he was the best prime time pitcher in baseball. The numbers are there to prove it. In 19 postseason starts with the Phillies, Diamondbacks, and Red Sox, Schilling went 11-2 with a 2.23 ERA. His teams played in 12 play-off series, winning 10. The 2004 Post season and World Series win. The legendary bloody sock that inspired his team. The 2007 World Series performance. He thrived on the post-season pressure because he loved scrutiny. He ate up the spot light on the mound. Yes, he has a huge ego that spews out of his mouth and blogs. But you need to have a gigantic ego to handle the pressure of poet-season play like he did.
He was also Mr. Clean in an era dominated by chemically enhanced athletes like Clemens, Bonds, A-Rod, McGuire, etc. People got on his case for trying to be the perfect father. As opposed to the whore chasing super-stars we love to
tear down. He was accused for being a nerd for pursuing his passion for “Everquest” by the same geeks who can quote every stat about the 1961 World Series.(I don’t know who played and I’m not going to look it up…crap..hold on…it was the Yankees and Reds) The guy was opinionated and in a position to communicate those opinions to the masses.
Whatever it was you hated about him, you can’t deny he was a winner. Doing it without roids(Clemens), phoning it in(Manny), or gambling on his team(Rose). Ty Cobb was a great ball player, but he was a racist prick. Despite my love of baseball I can never respect him. So Maybe I’m a hypocrite. Schilling had 3116 K’s in 23 Seasons. He’s not a Cy Young winner. 3 Time World Champion. Should he be in the hall of fame? Let’s get Louis Tiante in first, then we’ll talk about it.




I disagreed with his politics, but that does not matter on the field. We would not have the World Series wins (especially 2004) without him. I’d put him in the Hall. Thanks for everything, Curt.
Comment by Tom — March 24, 2009 @ 9:53 am
One of the eccentricities of the Baseball Hall of Fame is the level of subjectivity that often surrounds who is deserving of the Hall. Based on my observations, there are going to be some very compelling arguments both for and against #38 being inducted…
Arguments for:
– Best K-to-BB ratio of any pitcher (4.5-to-1)
– He was successful in an era where he was clean AND successful against confirmed hitters who were using performance enhancers
– Best post-season ERA of any pitcher, and an 11-2 post-season record
– 3 World Series rings with 3 DIFFERENT teams, most notably coming to Boston and helping to break the 86-year championship drought
– The bloody sock…baseball is a game of lore and legend and this is one of those stories that people will be telling for years
Arguments against:
– Low regular season win total
– No Cy Young awards
– No no-hitters
– Some writers don’t like him
We know first-hand that there are statistically-qualified players who never made it in, and some who took years to be elected…but if I had a vote (hometeam bias put as far aside as I can), I would say yes to the HOF.
Comment by Don Frye — March 24, 2009 @ 10:38 am
Hsu – I agree with you on certain levels of this blog. As a former Yankee fan, now a Washington Nationals fan (I know it is not an upgrade, but I refuse to jump on banwagons of teams) I have to say that when it came to a pitcher you want on the mound in October, Shill was the man. Now that Shill has retired lets send him out with 1 more song Hsu by the GREATEST BAND IN THE LAND RUSH! Lets play Limelight for the old man, and wish him well.
Comment by Hunter — March 24, 2009 @ 10:42 am
“Campaigned for cretins.” I wasn’t aware that Schilling campaigned for the Messiah. Thought he was a Republican. Oh well….
Comment by Michael the Other Massachusetts Republican — March 24, 2009 @ 11:17 am